Talk:Hameln II
From Gineipaedia, the Legend of Galactic Heroes wiki
(Created page with "==Crew Size== The DVD features give 25 as the crew. However in the Mutineer, Chapter III, when Reinhard is in the hostage situation on the bridge, I count 13 on the bridge. The...") |
Glacierfairy (Talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
The DVD features give 25 as the crew. However in the Mutineer, Chapter III, when Reinhard is in the hostage situation on the bridge, I count 13 on the bridge. There are the 2 existing medical staff and the injured captain. The chief engineer and the 3 enlisted characters on the engineering deck, for 21 in total. But then there are shots of an additional 6 enlisted crew in the engineering section, another 2 on their bunks in their quarters, and another 6 in the canteen. It is one single moment in time so those random enlisted people cannot be appearing twice or double counted. The total comes to 34 minimum. Post-hostage situation, the injured captain in his chair has a total of 4 medical staff around him. That makes 36 minimum. However given how long it took for me to find this discrepancy while consciously trying to keep head count, I am not sure whether any normal viewer would notice. [[User:Iracundus|Iracundus]] 23:18, 20 May 2016 (UTC) | The DVD features give 25 as the crew. However in the Mutineer, Chapter III, when Reinhard is in the hostage situation on the bridge, I count 13 on the bridge. There are the 2 existing medical staff and the injured captain. The chief engineer and the 3 enlisted characters on the engineering deck, for 21 in total. But then there are shots of an additional 6 enlisted crew in the engineering section, another 2 on their bunks in their quarters, and another 6 in the canteen. It is one single moment in time so those random enlisted people cannot be appearing twice or double counted. The total comes to 34 minimum. Post-hostage situation, the injured captain in his chair has a total of 4 medical staff around him. That makes 36 minimum. However given how long it took for me to find this discrepancy while consciously trying to keep head count, I am not sure whether any normal viewer would notice. [[User:Iracundus|Iracundus]] 23:18, 20 May 2016 (UTC) | ||
| + | :Wow, that's a major discrepancy you found 0.o How are we going to reconcile that with the DVD features in the article itself? And on a related note, what do you think of listing actual crew members in the infobox instead of just numbers as has been the case for all of our other ship articles? I don't think the former is feasible for most ship articles... [[User:Glacierfairy|Glacierfairy]] 10:16, 21 May 2016 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 10:16, 21 May 2016
Crew Size
The DVD features give 25 as the crew. However in the Mutineer, Chapter III, when Reinhard is in the hostage situation on the bridge, I count 13 on the bridge. There are the 2 existing medical staff and the injured captain. The chief engineer and the 3 enlisted characters on the engineering deck, for 21 in total. But then there are shots of an additional 6 enlisted crew in the engineering section, another 2 on their bunks in their quarters, and another 6 in the canteen. It is one single moment in time so those random enlisted people cannot be appearing twice or double counted. The total comes to 34 minimum. Post-hostage situation, the injured captain in his chair has a total of 4 medical staff around him. That makes 36 minimum. However given how long it took for me to find this discrepancy while consciously trying to keep head count, I am not sure whether any normal viewer would notice. Iracundus 23:18, 20 May 2016 (UTC)
- Wow, that's a major discrepancy you found 0.o How are we going to reconcile that with the DVD features in the article itself? And on a related note, what do you think of listing actual crew members in the infobox instead of just numbers as has been the case for all of our other ship articles? I don't think the former is feasible for most ship articles... Glacierfairy 10:16, 21 May 2016 (UTC)
